OFB Community Mailing Lists

The following archives are provided as a public service to the community. Opinions archived here do not necessarily represent the opinions of Open for Business or its contributors.

[CS-FSLUG] Macs replace university's Linux desktops

"國產 Wei-Yee Chan (Made in Chinar)" survivor at brisnet.org
Sun May 29 05:44:26 EDT 2005


I'm somewhat tempted to purchase a Mac mini to see what the fanfare is
all about, but then I'm stuck with a much more powerful PC now (at least
in terms of hardware), so I guess that'd just have to be put on hold. :-)

Timothy Butler wrote:

> More than you'd guess. I believe two system families have become  the
> norm in the U.S., if I recall recent statistics.
>
>     Apple's hardware really isn't expensive. If you compare a Mac 
> mini to a low end PC, it is just a bit more. If you compare a 
> PowerBook to a Pro-sumer or Business line laptop from the leading PC 
> manufacturers, again, you find it is about the same, perhaps even 
> cheaper. This is no small feat, for you are talking about a RISC 
> architecture (which, as you know is more expensive) loaded with 
> features that usually do not come standard. When NASA did 
> benchmarking of the PowerPC G5 vs. Intel chips, they did not even 
> bother to compare functions that could use the PowerPC's AltiVec 
> ("Velocity Engine") extensions, because the 128-bit AltiVec 
> subprocessor just is so much faster it wasn't even worth trying to 
> make the x86 do the job.
>
>     Apple is not going to compete with white box manufacturers, but 
> they are fairly competitive with high quality OEMs. Lots of people 
> like running GNU/Linux on Macs because Apple makes having a RISC 
> workstation affordable. You also have to consider that AppleCare is 
> generally ranked best in service and support by publications, so part 
> of the cost is going toward that too; not to mention that Apple does 
> much of its own R&D.
>
>     Well, the masses don't buy OEM copies beyond the one included 
> with their computer. So, $129 for Tiger (less at Amazon) is roughly 
> comparable with $99 for XP Home edition. And, when you consider that 
> Tiger has all of the extras included in XP Pro edition, you are 
> really saving $70 for the full OS X over the upgrade XP Pro.
>
>     I like the freeness of GNU/Linux too, although I especially 
> prefer the Freeness. My problem is I found I don't have "heaps of 
> time" as you put it. So, I switched to Macs, thereby permitting me to 
> continue to enjoy *nixy goodness without dedicating as much time to 
> the proposition. :-) Someday, I may return to GNU/Linux as my primary 
> system... although I may just run it on a PowerPC rather than an x86 
> (presently, I continue to run Linux on x86's).
>
>     -Tim
>
> ---
> Timothy R. Butler | "Turning and turning in the widening gyre
> tbutler at ofb.biz   |  The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
> timothybutler.us  |  Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
> uninet.info       |  Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world..."
>                                                 -- W. B. Yeats
>



More information about the Christiansource mailing list
Home About Connect: Twitter Facebook RSS
© 2001-2011 Universal Networks, All Rights Reserved. Some content rights may be held by Universal Networks' providers and used under license. Powered by ServerForest and SAFARI. Learn about our privacy policy here.