Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

By Alan Alan | Posted at 23:55

It may be that all of us have “hot buttons” – things we sometimes hear other people say that irritate us or even enrage us. A hot button for professors of religion (or at least for me) is to hear someone juxtapose the word “Christian” and the word “Catholic.”

Students have sometimes asked me if someone we both knew was a Christian or a Catholic, as though the two descriptions were mutually exclusive. Surely, every educated person should know that Catholics constitute one variety of Christian, as Protestants constitute another variety (or rather, a very large set of varieties!), and Orthodox another variety or set of varieties, and so forth? The question “Christian or Catholic?” is what is called in philosophy a category mistake. The first category, properly understood, includes the second, and includes others as well. The first category and the second category are not mutually exclusive. Asking “Christian or Catholic?” is a bit like asking “American or Missourian?” or “Sports fan or baseball fan?”

SOURCE: Library of Congress

My understanding of the meaning of the word “Christian” is that it is a descriptive term, not a normative one. That is, when I use the word Christian correctly it simply refers to anyone whose religion centers on the figure of Jesus of Nazareth, as the religion of Catholics, Protestants, Orthodox and others does, whether I personally agree with all which that person believes about Jesus or not, and whether or not I approve of any other of that person's beliefs or practices.

When I call someone a Christian, I am not necessarily endorsing all that person's beliefs, but only describing them, or at least some of them. I hasten to add here that, while I am a Presbyterian (a particular kind of Christian) I find myself in general agreement with most of the essentials of what the Catholics I know believe, as well as a great deal of what other categories of non-Presbyterian Christians believe. But, should I meet a person who claims to be a Christian, and who seems to understand that this term means positive identification with Jesus, I recognize the correctness of his or her use of the term, even if I do happen to disagree with other beliefs he or she holds. As D.T. Niles, the great churchman, used to say, you can be a Christian and have a very bad theology.

This is supposed to be a Reformation Day piece. What does the above have to do with the Reformation? Well:

I think it is obvious that what people mean when they say “Christian or Catholic” is “Protestant or Catholic.” The good old word “Protestant” seems to have disappeared from the vocabulary of the contemporary Christians who style themselves evangelicals. “Protestant” used to refer to those Christians who traced their particular understanding of the Christian faith back to the Reformation of the sixteenth century, to the teachings of Martin Luther and John Calvin and those other great leaders whom history calls the Reformers.

Those Reformers, in fact, liked being called Evangelical, a word that means “pertaining to the gospel.” They had an understanding of the gospel, the Christian message, which they felt had been lost during the previous thousand years of church history and which they now wished to proclaim once again. They did proclaim it, powerfully and successfully, so much so that the essentials of the Reformers' understanding of the Christian message are none other, I think, than the essentials of what today's evangelicals (as well as very many Christians who do not usually call themselves evangelicals) hold to be true. These essentials include:

Now, to repeat, I am certain that, in this day and age, there are a great many Christians who do not call themselves Protestants or evangelicals and who do not identify themselves with the Reformation, but who might claim the beliefs above as central tenets of their own faith. At least, these items are topics of dialogue and discussion among Christian groups today. The old boundary lines and battle cries of the wars among Christians have to a large extent faded. The essentials I listed above, or thinking about them, anyway, are the common heritage of Protestants and Catholics and other kinds of Christians. Still, those of us who belong to the churches that are historically linked to the Reformation may justly claim a peculiar relationship to these essentials of the faith. They are what we bring to dialogue and discussion among Christian groups. We can signal our identification with the Reformation and its heritage by calling ourselves “Protestants.” If you don't like that term, find another.

But, here's the bottom line: it is at best ignorant and at worst unChristlike bigotry to ask, “Christian or Catholic?” It may still be useful and helpful to ask, “Protestant or Catholic?” and to reflect on the inestimable treasure that the Reformation bequeathed to us.

Alan Meyers, Ph.D., is Professor Emeritus of Religion at Lindenwood University in St. Charles, Missouri.


Twitter Trackbacks for Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians - OFB.biz: Open for Business [ofb.biz] on Topsy.com

“wf-main”><div class=”wf-main-body”>

<div class=”concept-target”>

<div class=”body”>
<h2>Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians - OFB.biz: Open for Business</h2>


Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

On Reformation Day, we glorify God for what he accomplished in 16th century Germany through His servant, Dr. Martin Luther — the recovery of the gospel of salvation by grace through faith for Christ's sake.

That's what separates Christians & Catholics. The real gospel verses the false Catholic gospel of salvation by works. While Catholicism holds to their false doctrines they cannot be considered Christians, only those who follow Christ based on the true gospel are Christians.

Posted by Sthomas - Oct 31, 2010 | 18:49

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Oh my. We are saved by faith and works. This is clear scripture. The fact that Martin Luther, a catholic monk, decided to break away from the Church and even attempt to have the Book of James removed from the bible is a very sad thing. Rather than keeping ALL the tools of the Christian faith he chose to leave some behind. This of course led to others who didn't agree with what he had to say and the breakaway's continue even to this day. Most protestants don't even realize that Martin Luther held great love for Mary the mother of Christ until his death. This is not to say that there weren't problems within the church at the time. There certainly were, but, the answer was not to leave the faith that had clearly led millions to Jesus for about 1500 years. Before you bash a Catholic and say that they are not “True gospel Christians” you should give special thanks to God that thousands of Catholic monks made sure that you got a copy of the Bible in the first place. God bless you! May you study Catholicism and learn the truth of where you really come from.

Posted by Billy - Oct 31, 2010 | 21:11

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

The main distinction between Protestants and Catholics is, in fact, the very means by which we are saved - quite a distinction to make.

We are saved by grace, not works. Faith without works is dead faith, because real faith is evidenced by real works, repentance, and a life that conforms believers to become more and more like Christ. The root is faith, the fruit is works. If you try to plant a tree upside-down, it'll die. Likewise, looking to works for salvation leads to death. Who has anything to add to perfect life and brutal death of Jesus? To say we do is to say that Jesus isn't really able to save anyone on his own.

Posted by Scott - Nov 1, 2010 | 15:01

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Thank you, for a very excellent article.

Posted by Reynaldo Cabrera - Nov 1, 2010 | 20:06



HAIWONGROUP7

Introduce me blogging indonesia want to visit on your website and read the contents of article useful for me,
if any time please visit our website 

cara menurunkan berat badan

cara membesarkan alat vital pria dengan tangan

Posted by mas ulul - Oct 2, 2017 | 3:35

check cashing costa-mesa

With thanks on the subject of sending such type of highlights. My spouse and I sole just want to advise you that we all plainly read your internet site together with my spouse and I believe it is remarkably unique together with advantageous. At this time follow here check cashing costa-mesa Regards for excellent activity. Continue.

Posted by Pervez - Oct 7, 2017 | 16:17

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

enjoyed reading this thanks
http://thesciencebasedsixpack.co/

Posted by seth dean - Oct 20, 2017 | 22:03

HAIWONGROUP7


Introduce me blogging indonesia want to visit on your website and read the contents of article useful for me,
if any time please visit our website 

obat kuat

cara memperbesar penis

bokep

Posted by mas ulul - Oct 27, 2017 | 2:23

HAIWONGROUP7


Introduce me blogging indonesia want to visit on your website and read the contents of article useful for me,
if any time please visit our website 

obat kuat

cara memperbesar penis

bokep

Posted by mas ulul - Oct 27, 2017 | 2:23

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Do you need very rich sugar mummies that can take care of you?
If yes, visit sugar mummy webiste in order to get
sugar mummy phone numbers. Also, you can also join
the sugar mummy whatsapp group

Posted by Sugar Mummy - Nov 15, 2017 | 23:59

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Would you like to get sugar mummy direct phone number without agent?
visit our website to get sugar mummy phone numbers now.

Posted by Sugar Mummy - Nov 23, 2017 | 12:47

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Are you looking for a sugar mummy?
Click here>: i need a sugar mummy

Posted by Sugar Mummy - Nov 27, 2017 | 6:20

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Would you like to get some aussie cougars? if your answer is yes, join sugar mummy whatsapp group now. In the group, you can find the latest sugar mummy online

Posted by Sugar Mummy - Dec 6, 2017 | 19:52

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Get whatsapp numbers and chat with sugar mummies online

Posted by Sugar Mummy - Dec 9, 2017 | 14:30

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

sugar mummy website brings to you mature women seeking for love. Today, we have a sugar mama on whatsapp waiting to chat with you. She is ready to spend serious money on you and help you live your dream life.

Posted by Sugar Mummy - Dec 14, 2017 | 14:08

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

High quality backlink get free linksubmit

Posted by usha - Dec 21, 2017 | 17:49


Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Awesome! It sounds great. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing.. contract fencing

Posted by Robin jack - Dec 23, 2017 | 10:36

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

This is sugar mummy website and we are here to introduce to you women looking for men in any part of the world. They are older women and very rich.

Posted by Sugar Mummy - Jan 2, 2018 | 14:28

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

You have a decent point here!I thoroughly concur with what you have said!!Thanks for sharing your views…hope more individuals will read this article!!! chain link

Posted by Ashar Seo - Jan 9, 2018 | 11:51

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Would you like to chat with norwegian girls? If yes, visit the girls whatsapp numbers website to meet and chat with rich and cute girls.

Posted by Sugar Mummy - Jan 20, 2018 | 11:25

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

This was really an interesting topic and I kinda agree with what you have mentioned here! zimbabwefootball

Posted by Ashar Seo - Feb 15, 2018 | 11:48

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

New site is solid. A debt of gratitude is in order for the colossal exertion. tweede woning costa blanca

Posted by Robin jack - Feb 25, 2018 | 8:35


Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Good focuses you composed here..Great stuff…I think you've made some really fascinating points.Keep up the great work. high quality backlinks

Posted by Robin jack - Mar 27, 2018 | 11:57

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Real instructive and fantastic anatomical structure of articles , now that’s user pleasant (:. http://www.allencunninghampokerfan.net

Posted by Ashar Seo - Apr 5, 2018 | 6:49

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

appreciation for blogging!. “Shoot for the moon. Even if you miss, you’ll land among the stars.” by Les Brown.. link juice

Posted by rebecca martin - Apr 8, 2018 | 12:29

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Your site is truly cool and this is an incredible rousing article. Buy SolidWorks Premium 2018

Posted by Robin jack - Apr 9, 2018 | 10:36

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

More often than not I don't make remarks on sites, yet I'd like to say this article truly constrained me to do as such. Truly pleasant post! Grammarly Trial

Posted by Robin jack - Apr 15, 2018 | 18:28

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Extraordinary things you've generally imparted to us. Simply continue written work this sort of posts.The time which was squandered in going for educational cost now it can be utilized for studies.Thanks niche guest posts

Posted by edward fox - Apr 17, 2018 | 8:05

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

i think that everyone would love to watch some comedy shows because it is very entertaining` Father’s Day History

Posted by rebecca martin - Apr 19, 2018 | 10:26

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

I went over this site and I trust you have a considerable measure of superb data, spared to my bookmarks Zwembadbouw

Posted by Robin jack - May 1, 2018 | 10:37

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information much. I was seeking this particular information for a long time. Thank you and good luck. voyance-amour-eternel.com

Posted by Robin jack - May 2, 2018 | 0:27

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Crypto Coinscious provides details based on a market cap in USD and you can sort by rank, name, price, market cap, volume in 24 hours, change in 1 hour, change in 24 hours and available supply. Top Gainers show a list of top trending currencies based on last 24 hours change and Top losers show a list of most price dropped currencies from last 24 hours. Live Coin Watch

Posted by Robin jack - May 3, 2018 | 7:38

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

I think this is a better than average article. You make this data intriguing and locks in. You give perusers a ton to consider and I welcome that sort of composing. cheap Every Door Direct Mail Postcard Prints

Posted by Robin jack - May 4, 2018 | 9:46

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

A debt of gratitude is in order for the significant data and experiences you have so given here… cs 362 sql for data management phase 5 individual project ip colorado technical university ctu

Posted by Robin jack - May 7, 2018 | 11:12

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

If it's not too much trouble share more like that. Most Popular Hashtags

Posted by Robin jack - May 8, 2018 | 21:55

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

i think that everyone would love to watch some comedy shows because it is very entertaining` f8 auto liker

Posted by rebecca martin - May 12, 2018 | 8:52

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Hello, Neat post. There is a problem with your website in internet explorer, could test this¡K IE nonetheless is the marketplace leader and a large portion of people will leave out your excellent writing due to this problem. amerika gunlugum

Posted by Robin jack - May 13, 2018 | 9:34

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Much thanks for this valuable article. I like it. gamesinfoshop.com

Posted by Robin jack - May 13, 2018 | 13:12

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Companion, this site may be fabolous, i simply like it. his topical page

Posted by Robin jack - May 16, 2018 | 7:04

seo

A debt of gratitude is in order for the pleasant web journal. It was extremely valuable for me. I'm upbeat I discovered this site. Much obliged to you for offering to us,I too dependably discover some new information from your post. Mobile Phones

Posted by Robin jack - May 17, 2018 | 7:49

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

This article was composed by a genuine speculation author. I concur a hefty portion of the with the strong focuses made by the author. I”ll be back. senior medical alert fall detection

Posted by Robin jack - May 22, 2018 | 11:28

seo

This is extremely fascinating substance! I have completely appreciated perusing your focuses and have arrive at the conclusion that you are right about large portions of them. You are extraordinary. homepage

Posted by Robin jack - May 23, 2018 | 11:42


Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

I am certainly making the most of your site. You unquestionably have some extraordinary knowledge and incredible stories. Jittery Monks

Posted by Robin jack - May 24, 2018 | 12:31

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

I went over this site and I trust you have a ton of brilliant data, spared to my bookmarks cheap eddm printing

Posted by Robin jack - May 27, 2018 | 11:20

seo

Incredible Article it its truly instructive and inventive update us as often as possible with new upgrades. its was truly important. much obliged. http://educationaldepartments.com/

Posted by Robin jack - Jun 2, 2018 | 8:48

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

If you don't mind proceed with this incredible work and I anticipate a greater amount of your amazing blog entries. as for each strong website

Posted by Robin jack - Jun 5, 2018 | 23:33

seo

Fabulous .. Astonishing .. I'll bookmark your site and take the sustains likewise… I'm upbeat to discover such a large number of helpful data here in the post, we need work out more methods in such manner, a debt of gratitude is in order for sharing. best hiking boots under 100

Posted by Robin jack - Jun 11, 2018 | 9:26

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

You can hack your own treadmill desk or you can buy a commercial grade walking workstation. Either way, be sure to read our reviews of the best treadmill desk systems and under-desk treadmills specifically for office use. Our expert staff has been using and reviewing walking desks for over eight years, and our lab tests are the most rigorous known. treadmill desks

Posted by Robin jack - Jun 14, 2018 | 0:37

Re: Reformation Day 2010: Dividing Christians

Awesome! It sounds great. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing.. hungryreview

Posted by Robin jack - Jun 14, 2018 | 10:43

seo

Awesome! It sounds great. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing.. adsense make money online

Posted by Robin jack - Jun 20, 2018 | 9:00

Please enter your comment entry below. Press 'Preview' to see how it will look.

Name:
Sign In to Your Account
User Name:
Password:
Location:
Homepage:
E-mail:
Subject:
:mrgreen: :neutral: :twisted: :arrow: :shock: :smile: :???: :cool: :evil: :grin: :idea: :oops: :razz: :roll: :wink: :cry: :eek: :lol: :mad: :sad: :!: :?:
Home About Connect: Twitter Facebook RSS
© 2001-2012 Universal Networks, All Rights Reserved. Some content rights may be held by Universal Networks' providers and used under license. Powered by ServerForest and SAFARI. Learn about our privacy policy here.