Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

By Timothy Timothy | Posted at 22:36

When news broke of Steve Jobs’s death, their was an outpouring of sadness from both those who knew the man and those of us who knew only the products his farsighted perfectionism had helped to mold. Amidst the mourning over a technology pioneer and visionary, there was a contrary opinion from another technology pioneer and visionary known for his nearly 30 year long campaign against proprietary software. Richard Stallman was glad Jobs would not be able to create any more “jails” to lock people in.

To understand the statement, one needs to understand the man behind it. In 1983, Stallman founded the Free Software Foundation on the basis that software should be free for people to use and share. In the era when proprietary software – the sort that comes with lengthy legal agreements that prohibit you from sharing the software, editing the software’s code and so on – was just coming into its own, the FSF promised to keep the early spirit of collaborative innovation around.

Stallman came to hold this idea of freely sharable and editable software as a key ethical tenet and has been a tireless crusader for freeing information. When I have had the privilege to interview Stallman, one thing has always been clear: he took his values serious and is utterly consistent with them. It is hard to criticize that spirit – after all, much of what we enjoy about the Internet today comes from the software his organization created or helped to make accessible.

In Stallman’s ethical system, Apple is primarily evil, its design philosophy concerning the Mac and iOS little but a philosophy for how to imprison people in fruity holding cells. The problem is that Stallman’s position is one that demonstrates not only what is right in the Free Software world, but also exactly what is wrong with it.

In fixating on purity in software licensing, he risks becoming increasingly irrelevant to the true challenges to freedom in the present age. Today software is often a mere window to the Internet, bringing the real concern into sharp relief: not software freedom, but information freedom.

Steve Jobs’s Apple has done more in the last five years to make information freely accessible than the entire Free Software and Open Source community has in ten.

When the iPhone launched in 2007, suddenly normal, non-technically inclined people could enjoy e-mail, calendaring and, most importantly, full fledged web browsing on a mobile device that did not require a significant learning curve. And, because Apple recognized the problems Flash caused on the mobile front and steadfastly refused to support it, the company was able to use its considerable clout to push forward the open HTML5 standard on a web that was becoming increasingly dependent on Flash (and hence proprietary and buggy software).

Keeping information freely accessible is more than merely having Free Software tools to access it – or even having it accessible via open standards. If people cannot understand how to access the information, it might as well be locked away somewhere. Making computers easier to use is directly tied to the freedom of information.

Though the Free Software debates may be philosophically interesting, they are esoteric and generally irrelevant to peoples’ everyday lives. On the other hand, having a phone with a remarkably smart user interface that can access the “whole web” and not just mobile web sites is very relevant to everyday people.

Jobs’s visionary drive to create products that made difficult jobs simple, taking tasks previously reserved for the technologically elite and democratizing them via intuitive interfaces should be seen as a manner of championing freedom.

Take the iPod: while many pre-iPod music players insisted users needed to “mount” the player as a USB drive and manually drag music onto the drive from a folder – a task that can seem daunting to the novice user – Apple created a system where one simply plugs the music player in and everything else happens automatically. No learning curve and no continued maintenance of trying to keep the computer and music player in sync.

(Once Apple used the simplicity of the iPod to revitalize itself, as in the case with HTML5, Apple used its momentum to first advocate more consumer friendly forms of DRM and, eventually, DRM-free music.)

I know people who use iPhones regularly who would never have picked up a Palm Treo or BlackBerry, and much less utilized those phones to download apps, surf the web and listen to music. (And forget about the various attempts at a Free Software-based phone – those interfaces can be maddening even for the technologically inclined.)

The one shining Free Software answer to this challenge – Android – draws far more of its interface from imitation of Apple’s iOS than from any pre-iPhone design concept and, for that matter, is only quasi-Free, given Google’s ingenious maneuvers to reap Free and Open Source praise while still controlling who gets the relevant code and when.

The key is the first point. If one looks at a pre-iPhone demo of Android, it looks like a BlackBerry clone. Only post-iPhone does it take its touch friendly, application store driven face that people now know and love. And, lacking vision, it still remains harder to use and has only rarely has offered an easier way to do common tasks than iOS does.

The Linux desktop is even worse, a mishmash of Windows and Mac OS X interface concepts without a cohesive vision or strong desire to truly democratize information access by creating tools that simply tasks for non-technical users. Ubuntu has come closest to doing that, but is still harder to use than OS X and draws virtually all of its ease-of-use improvements over standard Linux from Mac OS X.

As Stallman, and even those far more moderate, lament how Jobs’s legacy is one of binding people under some tyrannical control, they miss the bigger, more important picture. Take away Apple, and Free Software users would have an even harder time viewing the whole web. Take away Apple, and the user interface improvements that have made computers significantly easier to use and allowed people to do sophisticated tasks simply would evaporate.

Sometimes the very worst sort of jail is the one that is wrapped in the guise of freedom few can take advantage of.

Timothy R. Butler is Editor-in-Chief of Open for Business.


Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Free software allows the creation of collaborative software that anyone can access, without needing to pay for it and with the security that they're constantly reviewed by a comunity. Thanks to this, nowadays many low income people can buy an used netbook for under 200$ with a GNU/Linux system installed, and many free aplications avaliable to install at no cost. Now THAT's making information freely accessible. We need more low-budget freddom-respectfull computing systems to fight poverty and cultural discrimination. Long live Free Software, the real information-democracy giver.

Posted by chila - Nov 3, 2011 | 20:50

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

I am a fan of open source and a fan of Apple. The comments Stallman said about Jobs, being in poor taste as they were, are hardly Stallman's biggest sins.

For that, in my view, look at what Stallman says about sex and children; about how it should be fine in public schools for kids to have uncensored access to porn. Stallman even goes so far to say we should relabel such porn as “educational material” and that blocking kids from this is harmful to them. Just utterly repulsive stuff. For more, do a Google search for the words: stallman sex children

He is a repulsive man who does more harm to open source than good those days. Linus Torvalds and Mark Shuttleworth are much better faces of open source, even if you do not use Ubuntu.

Posted by Techrights Watch - Oct 15, 2011 | 17:03

banh trung thu yen sao khanh hoa

Đây là dòng bánh trung thu cao cấp duy nhất trong nước. Bánh trung thu cao cấp Yến Sào Khánh Hòa sử dụng các nguồn nguyên liệu hoàn toàn là các món cao cấp như : yến sào, hải sâm, vi cá, trứng muối, mứt gừng, mứt bí… Đây hoàn toàn là nguồn nguyên liệu cao cấp và được chế biến với công thức riêng được nghiên cứu tỉ lệ kỹ lưởng để tạo ra một chiếc bánh thung thu thơm ngon, vừa ăn và không bị ngấy do ăn nhiều. Bánh đặc trưng với vị đậm đà nhờ phần gia vị đã được ủ và thấm đều kỹ càng, đây là một trong những đặc trưng mà các hiệu bánh trung thu khác không có được.

Posted by banh trung thu yen sao khanh hoa - Jul 5, 2017 | 7:11

poly

The most inspiring stuff commonly is probably the most dull or boring concern. a single rooster may not be in the same woody plant strip very long, and also the pets within the pine is a kind of weight, always want to consult the next stars, the particular fowl because the plants are really hesitant to facial expression an equal beautiful places day by day. poly

Posted by poly - Jul 12, 2017 | 13:07

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Posted by alena joseph - Aug 9, 2017 | 19:03



Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Cửa Hàng Sâm Yến Thịnh Phát xin giới thiệu các loại bánh trung thu yến sào banh trung thu yen sao khanh hoa 2017 đặc biệt thơm ngon .Bánh trung thu yến sào bán tại cửa hàng là sản phẩm của công ty nhà nước Yến Sào Khánh Hòa banh trung thu yen sao .Đây là các sản phẩm được sản xuất trên một quy trình khép kín đảm bảo các sản phẩm đạt tiêu chuẩn vềbanh trung thu yen sao khanh hoa
banh trung thu yen sao mặt an toàn hợp vệ sinh cũng như có chất lượng hết sức thơm ngon và đặc biệt .Các loại bánh trung thu được đóng gói bằng các loại bao bì hết sức đẹp mắt và trang trọng , có thể làm quà để tặng cho người thân và gia đình trong dịp trung thu .

Posted by Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman - Aug 15, 2017 | 10:33

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

life is beautiful; happiness is infinite. Experience life, memorable. Life is like a cup of coffee, bitter with astringent. Life is also bitter life, the term of life from the bitter spent, might as well make life from happiness through. Coffee is bitter, from which we can add some Cheap Nike Shoes For Men sugar, you Nike Men Shoes Outlet can add milk. But what about life? Life will not be as coffee as more sugar and then add some milk, they can not suffer? Life is on their own, is bitter is not a little bit of sugar can be solved by a little sugar, but by their own solution. The road is still rough, it is difficult to grasp, but the scenery is still, the heart is still; all the way to run around, despite the labor, hard to sustenance, hard to say, can no longer come back, but also less than the beginning; Tired, Xu is more and more relaxed, Xu is more and more helpless, can always have to go, keep walking, has been moving forward. Not afraid of strangers, not afraid of no way, because the foot is the road, the road next to the road! Love is not a feeling, but a feeling. Often inexplicable loss, it is because there is a castle in mind, there is a poignant fairy tale; often journeying in a daze, it is because the hearts of one side of the sky, there is a touch of clear and graceful silhouette silhouette; often quietly tears, It is because the tears is a call, is a piercing shock. Not forget, but can not forget; not hurt, but has been in the habit, in life. True words are silent, not in words. Each other, is the heart of a cup of tea, that moment of melting, enjoy the flow, has been turned into tears; each other, is one another, each other is the best of the years, the most sincere meet each other, that moment of throbbing, Women Free Run enjoy interpretation, has become a habit; Dream of the eternal theme, that bit of bone feelings, enjoy surging, has been cemented into life. Perhaps no tomorrow no future, some just that share of dedication, heart calm, the heart of the spend! Dream, in fact, is a lonely trip. Despite the distant, bumpy, as long as there is a dream, the pace will be easy; despite how many ridicule, how many doubts, as long as determined, wind and rain is baptism; despite black and blue, painful heart, as long as there is love, everything is possible. The dream of the years, is monotonous and gorgeous; dream of life, is bitter and sweet; a dream of life, is natural, it is wonderful, beautiful! Looked at the head, staring at the distant horizon, but his own tears; close your eyes, listen to is not familiar with the songs, but their own heart; out of hand, to seize the feelings are not deep, but the appointment of white hair The moonlight

Posted by solo - Aug 25, 2017 | 5:57

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Michael Kors Package Deals
mk shoulder bags wholesale
michael kors crossbody handbags
michael kors jet set checkbook wallet
michael kors satchel
michael kors checkbook wallet black
Michael Kors Shoulder Tote
nike shoes free
Nike Air Jordan 26
Nike Air Jordan Hydro
Nike Air Max Command
nike sneakers cheap
nike women's free 5.0 running shoes
coach luggage mens
coach satchel clearance
coach city zip tote
nike sneakers air max
nike sneakers cheap
coach bags for sale
Cheap Nike Shoes Online
Nike Jordan Shoes
mk shoulder bags on sale
cheap michael kors bags
Michael Kors Package Deals
mk shoulder bags wholesale
Michael Kors Shoulder Tote
michael kors shirts
michael kors T-shirts
Michael Kors Selma.
Cheap Michael Kors Shoulder Bags
michael kors trousers
michael kors women's Clothing
nike air foamposite pro
Nike air force
coach wallet outlet
coach hobo bags outlet
Nike Heels Boots<br />
michael kors crossbody handbags
michael kors jet set checkbook wallet
michael kors satchel
michael kors checkbook wallet black
Nike Hyperdunk<br />
Nike Kids Shoes<br />
nike sb dunks
nike free running shoes
lebron james nike shoes
Nike King<br />
Nike Lunar<br />
Michael kors factory outlet.
Micheal kors satchelbags
Nike Lunar Haze<br />
Nike Shox<br />
Nike Women Shoes
shoes outlet
Light Up Shoes
Coach Accessories
michael kors kids shoes
Michael Kors Mens sale
mk backpack mens
Nike Pepper Shoes<br />
Nike Sandals<br />
Nike SB<br />
michael kors clothing online
michael kors coats
michael kors jackets
Michael Kors Wallet
Michael Kors Handbags Outlet
michael kors bracelet sale
michael kors on sale watches
michael kors jeans
michael kors jumpers cardigans
mk bag outlet
Michael kors chelsea
michael kors crossbody bags

Posted by rainahuang - Aug 29, 2017 | 3:29

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

well if you can see that after steven jobs death, apple company didn't get any big loos or any loophole in it.Android App Development companies were providing them a very tough time but Apple maintains his standard.

Posted by Magnus - Sep 21, 2017 | 13:54

check cashing lemon-grove

This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives in depth information. Now click here check cashing lemon-grove Thanks for this nice article.

Posted by Pervez - Sep 24, 2017 | 11:13

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

It is a horror movie of about 1h and 52m. Pet dog of Rod and Carolyn died in mysterious circumstances. showbox apk

Posted by Alexandr Lukin - Sep 24, 2017 | 17:07

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Later, they found that a spirit was harming their daughter, Andrea. Frightened by these conditions, Rod and Carolyn called on the investigators to help them out with this mess. Showbox

Posted by Alexandr Lukin - Sep 25, 2017 | 13:19


Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Real-time PokeMesh Apk Download Pokemon GO Map PokéMesh latest version for Android with filter pokemes notification Pokemesh

Posted by Alexandr Lukin - Sep 28, 2017 | 13:31

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

We’ve talked about CinemaBox HD app; what it is, how you can get it for Android and what you can do to fix some common errors on it. CinemaBox

Posted by Alexandr Lukin - Sep 30, 2017 | 6:22

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman
Posted by Alexandr Lukin - Sep 30, 2017 | 14:58

HAIWONGROUP7

Introduce me blogging indonesia want to visit on your website and read the contents of article useful for me,
if any time please visit our website 

obat kuat

cara membesarkan alat vital pria dengan tangan

Posted by mas ulul - Oct 4, 2017 | 0:22

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Appreciate the fact that thanks to Lucky Patcher will be able to run offline applications that previously required Internet connection.Lucky Patcher

Posted by Evgeni Igorevich - Oct 6, 2017 | 18:07

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman
Posted by lineforpc - Oct 17, 2017 | 4:02

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Download Mobdro. Apk 2017 for your device and love cyclosis movies, videos, and lots more democratic channels. You can ticker all your lost TV screening survive this youtube telecasting streaming mobdro android app for free. Different tv solving formats are useable on this Mobdro apk for Humanoid and you can bask observance it in minor and big Android devices. Check out Mobdro reviews to acknowledge more approximately them. Is Mobdro dependable to current online videos? Yes, course, they do. Download Mobdro Apk for Humanoid http://playboxmovies.com/mobdro-app/

Posted by Alexandr Lukin - Oct 20, 2017 | 13:42

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

thank for information, this article very helpful
free game twist vouchar card generator

Posted by sumita - Oct 26, 2017 | 15:15

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

But it’s famed dislodge those apps ask a fee to get amused that is why Mobdro APK come into creation. On this app, you get two versions freemium and bounty. Mobdro Freemium: You wickerwork download it from our prescribed nexus disposed infra. As its name suggest freemium is a unfreeze variant which is useable for everybody to download and use.
Solitary install it onto your Humanoid device, Windows Pc or laptop and jump observation release inexhaustible streams of your favorite TV channels from everywhere the mankind. Mobdro application to run in PC and Mac

Posted by Alexandr Lukin - Oct 28, 2017 | 18:16


Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

This is uncommon information for understudies. This article is extraordinarily helpful i genuinely like this blog thankful free game stop gift card generator

Posted by gamestop card - Nov 11, 2017 | 15:57

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Thanks for the best blog. It was very useful for me, keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. Thanks for sharing the useful information. aşk büyüsü

Posted by aşk büyüsü - Nov 16, 2017 | 18:46

http://walmartcreditcardlogin.online/

http://walmartcreditcardlogin.online/ Are you a shopping lover? Then you will surely love this Walmart Credit Card

Posted by http://walmartcreditcardlogin.online/ - Nov 17, 2017 | 7:38

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

I have bookmarked your website, the articles are path superior to anything other comparable sites.. a debt of gratitude is in order for an extraordinary online journal! wasp removal tucson

Posted by Robin jack - Dec 10, 2017 | 15:18

nấm linh chi

Nơi bán nấm linh chi đỏ tại quận Bình Thạnh là một trong những loại thảo dược tự nhiên Cửa hàng nấm linh chi đỏ tại tỉnh Gia Lai, có mặt ở rất nhiều quốc gia trên thế giới như Nhật Bản Cửa hàng nấm linh chi đỏ tại Hà Nội, Hàn Quốc, Hoa Kì… Trong các loại nhân sâm kể trên thì nhân sâm hàn quốc Nơi bán nấm linh chi đỏ tại tỉnh Gia Lai luôn được hàng triệu người trên khắp thế giới săn lùng và tìm kiếm bởi những giá trị tuyệt vời Nơi bán nấm linh chi đỏ tại tỉnh Đồng Nai. Từ xưa đến nay những công dụng của loại nhân sâm này vẫn được mọi người lưu truyền Nơi bán nấm linh chi đỏ tại Hải Phòng và ứng dụng vào trong đời sống đặc biệt là chăm sóc sức khỏe của con người. Củ nhân sâm Hàn Quốc Nơi bán nấm linh chi đỏ tại Hà Nội chính là nhân sâm Hàn Quốc ở dạng tươi chưa qua Cửa hàng nấm linh chi đỏ tại TP HCM sơ chế thành các sản phẩm. Củ nhân sâm Hàn Quốc Địa chỉ nấm linh chi đỏ tại Hà Nội có những vai trò và tác dụng vô cùng to lớn đối với con người.

Posted by nấm linh chi - Dec 13, 2017 | 9:53

Re: Freedom, Apple and Richard Stallman

Exceptionally valuable post. This is my first time i visit here. I discovered such a large number of fascinating stuff in your site particularly its exchange. Truly its awesome article. Keep it up. TwentyMotion

Posted by rebecca martin - Dec 16, 2017 | 9:28

Please enter your comment entry below. Press 'Preview' to see how it will look.

Name:
Sign In to Your Account
User Name:
Password:
Location:
Homepage:
E-mail:
Subject:
:mrgreen: :neutral: :twisted: :arrow: :shock: :smile: :???: :cool: :evil: :grin: :idea: :oops: :razz: :roll: :wink: :cry: :eek: :lol: :mad: :sad: :!: :?:
Home About Connect: Twitter Facebook RSS
© 2001-2012 Universal Networks, All Rights Reserved. Some content rights may be held by Universal Networks' providers and used under license. Powered by ServerForest and SAFARI. Learn about our privacy policy here.